Sunday, 18 December 2016

Science and cowboys

Broke Back Mountain, a movie about two cowboys who develop feelings for each other and consummate their feelings in five minutes of disturbing cinematography, forever changed my perspective on cowboys.  Gone were the rough and ready cowboys from the westerns of my youth.  Care free, sometimes lawless, always ready to ride off into the sunset without a concern, my image of cowboys would never be the same.  There are another form of cowboys however, those rough and ready tradesman who do a shoddy job, take your money, and run.  These cowboys are a dime a dozen, and initially it can be difficult to differentiate them from a quality tradesman.  Trade professions have sought to combat this dilemma by developing associations such as The Master Builders Association, which guarantee that their members will maintain certain ethics and standards, and if not, will be held accountable (“Registered Master Builders,”n.d.).  Accountability is key to ensuring quality, as taking pride in one's work is sadly not enough motivation for some.

Maintaining ethical standards in all professions is essential for a well-functioning society, and probably none more essential than in the field of science.  If science is a profession in which individuals cooperate together in order to achieve common goals, as describe by Resnik (1998), then a set of rules and standards is essential to ensure that everyone can work collaboratively, knowing that a certain quality of practice is being maintained.  Ethical standards such as honesty, carefulness, social responsibility, efficiency, and respect, guide the practice of science, with the aim to advance human knowledge, eliminate ignorance and solve practical problems (Resnik, 1998).  Lofty goals require lofty ideals, which the scientific community are at pains to maintain.  The practice of peer review opens up the methods used for scientific discovery to be tested by others.  Critical analysis of each minute step ensures quality practice, and remaining answerable to your peers, ensures accountability is maintained.

Whether it is the advice from your doctor, which fuel you should put in your car, or whether to take supplementary vitamins every morning with your breakfast, we all rely on science in our daily lives.  Having an assurance therefore, that the information we receive is reliable, as it has been subjected to testing and scrutiny, should offer some piece of mind.  Knowing that the scientific community function within a set of ethical standards offers the layman some security that those tasked with advancing human knowledge, do so in accordance with ethical social norms.  No system is perfect however, and occasionally the odd cowboy might ride into town.  The vigilance of his peers therefore to call him out, rope him down, and string him up, is critical for ethical standards to be upheld.  Those who choose not to meet these standards should be held to account, chased out of town, and left to wander the periphery of the scientific communities, huddling together in isolation like in a sordid scene from Broke Back Mountain.


Reference:

Registered Master Builders, (n.d.).  Retrieved from http://www.masterbuilder.org.nz/RMBA/About_Us/RMBA/About_Us/About_Us.aspx?hkey=be67aaf4-5fd3-4f1c-8d34-2e58dc3b8e0a

Resnick, B.D. (1998).  The ethics of science: an introduction. Retrieved from http://sharifphilosophy.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/The_Ethics_of_Science.pdf

3 comments:

Unknown said...

Shane, what a great write!
I enjoyed that, thank You.
You gave an excellent introduction (you captured the audience very quickly). The mid-part was well researched and offered formal information on your Blog subject. Then the end rounded it out with practical references such as the example of "advice from your doctor......... which fuel you should put in your car..... whether to take supplementary vitamins every morning".
It flowed well, and the link back to cowboys at the end gave it a full story affect.
Awesome!
Lease

At times it Rhymes said...

Once again you nailed at Shane, I just had a very graphic last sentence, imagining all my tradie mates in a broke back type mountain scene! Ooh. Glad that has now dissipated.

You make an excellent point, I agree with the ethics side of things, I also believe that people need to take pride in what they do in this lifetime. I am a firm believer that if your heart is not in it, you will never produce something that you are truly 100% proud of. That is where I think a lot of shocking cases creep up from.

Science is also a very lucrative industry, you really do get what you pay for (even if it's not ethical). Let's be honest, if we used our brain's and really challenged some of the research coming out things would eventually change. I say name and shame them !

An excellent example which has actually stuck in my mind from living in the UK, would be: Diet coke being sugar free and healthy... NO
It will never be healthy, but scientific research and marketing has led the masses to believe that consuming "sugar free" is a really healthy option?

*sigh*

Thanks again Shane, wonderful topic that you have chosen this week! Look forward to doing this team assignment with you all and reading your next blog post.

Cheers
Lauren

Jordan Springer 119.155 said...

Loved your introduction, you always start your blogs in such a clever and creative way. You have a naturally humorous writers voice too I must say! The points you raise about ethics in society and ethical standards make for a very informative blog. Doing this research into ethics for your blog will be very beneficial for the group report. Ethics is an extremely important topic and its very broad in nature, having things like business ethics and science ethics. I actually took an ethics paper earlier this year and found it extremely beneficial to being able to understand the ways of the world.
Another great blog post Shane well done.
Jordan